The 2023 "Be The Change: Gender Equality in the Music Industry" study by Luminate, TuneCore, and Believe surveyed 1,656 music industry professionals and musicians from 109 countries. The study found that 34% of women in the music industry experienced sexual harassment or abuse at work, with rates rising to 42% for trans people and 43% for nonbinary people. Additionally, 58% of respondents disagreed with the statement that "everyone has an equal opportunity to succeed in the music industry." A separate 2018 Music Industry Research Association survey found that 72% of female musicians reported sex-based discrimination and 67% reported being victims of sexual harassment—nearly double the rate for U.S. women generally.
Safety & Harassment at a Glance
What safety & harassment looks like in the evidence
Online abuse, content theft, deepfakes, and the failure of platforms to protect creators.
70 documented items tie this concern to 43 different creative disciplines in the current dataset.
How this issue appears across disciplines
Each group below points back to a discipline page and the original source links behind it.
Music
1 evidence item
Audio & Podcasting
1 evidence item
The UNESCO/ICFJ global study found that 73% of women journalists and media creators surveyed have experienced online attacks connected to their work, including threats of physical violence (25%) and sexual violence (18%). A third of women journalists have considered leaving the profession due to online abuse, and 42% reported that offline harm linked to online threats has more than doubled since 2020. For women in public-facing audio roles such as podcasting, the lack of platform-level moderation tools and the intimacy of voice-based media create heightened vulnerability to targeted abuse and doxxing.
Architecture & Design
1 evidence item
A 2024 Architects Registration Board (ARB) survey of 898 architecture professionals found that 41% had experienced bullying, 33% had experienced discrimination, and 10% had experienced sexual misconduct—rates higher than comparable professions including academia and medicine. Among female architects, 25% reported unwelcome sexual advances and 38% experienced unwelcome sexual comments, while 53% of women had encountered insults, stereotypes, or jokes relating to protected characteristics. A third of professionals said they would not feel confident raising concerns about misconduct, fearing career repercussions. A separate 2025 RIBA/Fawcett Society report found that 35% of women architects experienced sexual harassment at work, 54% discovered they were being paid less than male peers at the same level, and women in architecture represent only 27.1% of AIA membership despite decades of diversity initiatives.
Visual Arts
2 evidence items
In the landmark Andersen v. Stability AI class action, U.S. District Judge William Orrick ruled that visual artists may pursue copyright claims against Stability AI, Midjourney, DeviantArt, and Runway AI for training generative models on billions of images scraped without consent from the LAION-5B dataset—a collection of 5.85 billion images harvested from the internet. A 2023 survey by Book an Artist found that 74% of artists consider AI scraping of their work unethical, 89% believe current copyright laws are inadequate, and 73% want to be asked for permission before their artwork is used to train AI. The scale of the crisis drove over one million artists to flee Instagram for the anti-AI platform Cara in June 2024 after Meta announced it would use posted images to train its AI models.
A 2024 Nordic Council of Ministers survey found that 50% of visual artists have experienced threats, violence, or harassment at some point in their careers, with 15% affected within the preceding 12 months. Among performing artists, 62% of women reported experiencing threats or harassment compared to 45% of men, and nearly a third of women reported sexual harassment versus 13% of men. Respondents noted that harassment leads artists to self-censor their creative expression, posing a direct threat to artistic freedom. The study found that between 36% and 61% of artists across all surveyed disciplines had experienced threats, violence, or harassment at work.
Film & Video
1 evidence item
A UNI Global Union survey of 28 unions in 22 countries, representing over 150,000 behind-the-scenes crew members, found that 62% said work schedule intensity negatively impacted their mental wellbeing. More than a quarter of respondents in independent television production reported that extreme fatigue had resulted in grave accidents. Crew members routinely work 14-18 hour days, with some working 16+ hours daily for 7 days a week. In 2014, crew member Gary Joe Tuck died after falling asleep at the wheel following an 18-hour shift on the set of "Longmire."
Writing & Publishing
1 evidence item
PEN America's Freedom to Write Index 2024 documented at least 375 writers imprisoned in 40 countries worldwide -- the highest number of countries recorded in the Index's six-year history, up from 339 writers in 2023. China remains the world's top jailer with 118 writers behind bars, followed by Iran (43) and Saudi Arabia (23). Asia-Pacific and the Middle East/North Africa regions together account for 76% of all imprisoned writers globally. The number of imprisoned women writers rose to 59 (16% of total), up from 51 in 2023. Online commentators accounted for 203 of those jailed, while 127 journalists were imprisoned for their work. The count has risen every year since the Index began, from 238 in 2019 to 375 in 2024, revealing an accelerating global crackdown on literary and journalistic expression.
Performing Arts
2 evidence items
AI-generated deepfakes threaten performers' livelihoods and likeness rights. In 2024, Scarlett Johansson confronted OpenAI after it released an AI voice closely resembling hers without consent. In 2025, SAG-AFTRA filed an unfair labor practice charge over the AI-generated use of James Earl Jones' voice for Darth Vader in Fortnite, arguing it violated member rights and deprived living performers of potential work. The union's NO FAKES Act aims to create the first-ever federal intellectual property right in voice and likeness.
Source: SAG-AFTRA - Artificial IntelligenceA 2024 European Labour Authority study found that 7.7 million workers in the EU's cultural and creative industries -- 3.8% of the total workforce -- face systematically precarious conditions. Reliance on self-employment and temporary contracts leaves the majority without essential protections including health insurance and pensions. Widespread undeclared work, compounded by cash payments and unregistered events, further erodes stability. A companion Creative Pulse Survey of 1,204 European artists found that nearly half reported poor working conditions, over two-thirds lacked sufficient social protection, and reliance on multiple income sources was most common in the performing arts. 96% of respondents supported adopting an EU-wide "Status of the Artist" framework to guarantee fair remuneration and social protections.
Photography
1 evidence item
2024 was the deadliest year for journalists in the Committee to Protect Journalists' 30+ year history, with at least 124 journalists and media workers killed globally. In 2025, the death toll reached 129. Freelancers were disproportionately affected: 43 freelance journalists were killed in 2024 alone, 31 of them Palestinians in Gaza. Freelance photojournalists face heightened vulnerability due to their independent status, lack of institutional legal protections, and absence of employer-provided insurance or safety equipment.
Gaming & Interactive Media
1 evidence item
SAG-AFTRA's video game strike lasted from July 26, 2024 to June 11, 2025 -- nearly 11 months -- over AI protections for voice actors and motion capture performers. The core issue: companies sought the ability to train AI on performers' voices and likenesses without consent or fair compensation. The resolved contract was ratified with 95.04% approval, providing 15.17% compounded pay increases and AI consent/disclosure requirements. The strike highlighted systemic power imbalances between performers and studios.
Journalism & News Media
1 evidence item
The Columbia Journalism Review documents that in 2025, press freedom came under direct attack in the United States, with the government turning rhetoric against the press into concrete action to restrict, punish, and intimidate journalists. There were 170 reports of assaults on journalists in 2025, with 160 of them at the hands of law enforcement. Assaults on journalists soared more than 50% in 2024 compared to the previous year, and 314 incidents of violations of press freedom were documented in 2024 alone, ranging from legislative bans on reporting to physical attacks.
Graphic & Digital Design
1 evidence item
Typeface designers face a uniquely difficult intellectual property landscape: their content is expensive to create but easy to steal. A study found that 63% of designers have used pirated fonts at some point in their careers. In the US, the shapes of typefaces are not eligible for copyright (only the font software is protected), leaving type designers with limited legal recourse. Notable lawsuits include Brand Design Co.'s $3.5 million suit against NBC Universal over approximately 20,000 unauthorized downloads of the Chalet typeface (2012), and Production Type's 2023 copyright suit against Nike for unlicensed use of Kreuz Light, seeking $150,000 per infringement.
Fashion & Textile Arts
1 evidence item
The fashion industry employs approximately 60 million factory workers worldwide, yet less than 2% earn a living wage. In Bangladesh, the minimum wage was raised by 56% to $113/month after widespread protests in late 2023 that resulted in the death of at least four garment workers and imprisonment of over 100 workers and advocates -- but this still falls short of the $210/month living wage unions require. In Cambodia, one in three women garment workers report experiencing sexual abuse or violence at work; in Bangladesh, that figure is 80%.
Animation & Motion
1 evidence item
A 2024 United Nations report condemned Japan's anime industry for exploiting workers, citing excessive hours, low pay, and disregard for intellectual property rights. The report warned of "potential collapse" if reforms are not implemented. Over one-third of anime studios reported losses in 2024 despite record revenues. In response, Japan enacted the Freelance Act in November 2024 — the country's first freelancer protection law — but enforcement remains uncertain for the estimated 50% of animators working as independent contractors.
Crafts & Traditional Arts
3 evidence items
Cultural appropriation functions as an asymmetric extraction of Indigenous knowledge, art, spirituality, and identity for capitalist consumption. Non-Indigenous individuals and companies mass-produce culturally significant items at lower prices, directly undercutting Indigenous artisan economies. People make contacts with Indigenous communities, pay them a pittance for their crafts, then upsell while undercutting the real artists trying to make an honest and dignified living. Globalization has led to the commodification of Indigenous cultural expressions, reducing unique art forms to commercial goods stripped of their cultural significance.
Source: Cultural Survival - Cultural Appropriation: Another Form of Extractivism of Indigenous CommunitiesAs much as 80% of jewelry marketed as "Indian-made" may be counterfeit. The Indian Arts and Crafts Board has received over 1,700 complaints of alleged violations of the Indian Arts and Crafts Act. Despite penalties of up to $250,000 and 5 years imprisonment for individuals (and $1,000,000 for businesses), enforcement remains insufficient. In one case, a California man was sentenced to 37 months in prison for running a counterfeit Hopi jewelry operation that siphoned roughly $500,000 from collectors. This systemic fraud erodes the economic and cultural livelihood of Native American artists, craftspeople, and tribes.
Forced labor persists in global craft supply chains in 2025 despite regulatory pressure. The ILO documented 665 cases of migrant worker abuse globally in 2024 alone, with exploitation concentrated deep in lower-tier suppliers where oversight is weakest. Traditional supply chains routinely exploit producers in developing countries, paying low wages while exploiting their lack of bargaining power. Craft and textile artisans in the Global South face particular vulnerability, as brands capture the value of "artisanal" and "handmade" marketing while tier-2 and tier-3 producers see minimal returns. Worker-Driven Social Responsibility (WSR) initiatives are emerging as alternatives to ineffective corporate audit models.
Content Creation & Digital Media
1 evidence item
Content creators, especially women, face escalating dangers from parasocial relationships that cross into obsession and violence. Twitch streamer Pokimane revealed years of stalking and sexual harassment by obsessive fans. Most women earning a living on Twitch know what it's like to have viewers develop obsessive feelings of romantic and sexual entitlement—extreme harassment, rape and death threats, blackmailing, and stalking have become regular workplace hazards. Platforms provide inadequate tools and no institutional support to protect creators from these dangers.
Source: PsychVarsity - Parasocial Relationships: Why We Feel Close to Creators and When It Goes Too FarCulinary Arts
1 evidence item
The federal tipped minimum wage has been frozen at $2.13/hour since 1991. The Department of Labor found 1,170 tip credit violations and recovered over $29 million in stolen wages from restaurant workers in 2023 alone. About two-thirds of tipped restaurant workers are women, who are three times more likely than the average worker to live in poverty. In a 2014 survey, 80% of respondents experienced sexual harassment in their restaurant workplace, with female employees receiving the $2.13 wage experiencing twice the harassment rate of women in higher-minimum-wage states.
Creative Technology
2 evidence items
The xz Utils backdoor (CVE-2024-3094) revealed how a malicious actor exploited open source maintainer burnout through a three-year social engineering campaign. The sole maintainer, Lasse Collin, was pressured via sock-puppet accounts into ceding co-maintainer access after citing overwork and burnout. The attacker then injected a backdoor into a library used across virtually all Linux distributions. CISA concluded the incident "highlighted the fragility of key points in the open source ecosystem" and "the very real and ongoing risks created by maintainer burnout."
In August 2024, U.S. District Judge William Orrick ruled that visual artists may pursue copyright claims against Stability AI, Midjourney, DeviantArt, and Runway AI, finding that Stable Diffusion was built "to a significant extent on copyrighted works" and was "created to facilitate that infringement by design." The LAION training dataset contained 5 billion images scraped from the internet without consent. Over 30 copyright infringement lawsuits have been filed against generative AI developers, yet no final decisions have been reached, leaving AI artists in legal limbo -- unable to protect their work or establish clear rights.
Education & Knowledge Creation
1 evidence item
Telegram piracy led to an estimated Rs 2,000 crore (roughly $240+ million) in annual revenue loss for India's e-learning sector alone, with over 6,000 piracy groups on Telegram, of which 1,000+ groups have more than 10,000 viewers each. Pirated copies of entire video courses are circulated in groups with tens of thousands of students. Even a single pirated link shared in a Telegram group can reach thousands, destroying the revenue model for individual course creators who may have invested months building their material.
Laboratory Scientists & Researchers
1 evidence item
A survey of over 700 international postdoctoral researchers at Harvard Medical School revealed that more than 40% spent over a month in their home countries waiting to renew US visas, with 5% spending more than six months -- effectively unable to work. Scholars from Asia experienced longer delays and higher costs than Europeans. In September 2025, the H-1B visa fee was raised to $100,000, while new requirements included mandatory disclosure of social media accounts and prolonged vetting. A Nature analysis found US-based scientists submitted 32% more applications to positions abroad in early 2025 compared to 2024, while applications to US jobs from European and Chinese scientists plummeted, signaling a brain drain from the world's largest research enterprise.
Academic Writers & Scholarly Publishing
1 evidence item
STAT News reports that the NIH has recognized the core dysfunctions of the scientific publication economy, including the unchecked growth of publishing fees and the overreliance on unpaid peer labor. Globally, researchers contribute an estimated $6 billion in unpaid peer review labor when rejected manuscripts are included. The system functions through institutional coercion: academics must publish in prestigious journals to secure tenure, grants, and career advancement, yet these same journals require them to provide free editorial labor as a condition of participation. Early-career researchers are disproportionately harmed, as they bear the heaviest reviewing burden while having the least job security, creating a cycle of exploitation that the NIH proposal seeks to disrupt by making peer review compensation an allowable publication cost.
Data Scientists & Computational Researchers
2 evidence items
A Proof News investigation revealed that Nvidia scraped YouTube videos to train its Cosmos AI model, with VP of Research Ming-Yu Liu writing in an internal email about building "a video data factory that can yield a human lifetime visual experience worth of training data per day." Nvidia used dozens of virtual machines with rotating IP addresses to evade YouTube's detection systems. Companies including Meta, Microsoft, and Nvidia extracted over 15.8 million videos from more than 2 million YouTube channels without creator consent, prompting class-action lawsuits alleging unjust enrichment and unfair competition.
MIT Technology Review documented how AI companies have systematically scraped training data without consent or compensation, prompting a wave of lawsuits and licensing deals. The New York Times alleges millions of copyrighted articles were used to train AI models without consent. LinkedIn faces a class-action lawsuit for allegedly harvesting private messages for AI training. Reddit sued Perplexity AI for obtaining data "using false identities, proxies and other antisecurity techniques." Meanwhile, data scientists and researchers whose public datasets, code, and analyses were scraped for training have no mechanism for attribution, opt-out, or compensation -- their computational work treated as raw material for corporate AI products.
Source: AI companies are finally being forced to cough up for training dataIndustrial & Product Design
2 evidence items
Amazon identified, seized, and disposed of more than 15 million counterfeit products in 2024, more than double the 7 million seized in 2023. The counterfeit trade accounts for over $500 billion annually globally, and e-commerce platforms remain a prime vector. While Amazon's AI tools now block over 99% of suspected infringements proactively, its vast third-party marketplace makes comprehensive enforcement essentially impossible. For independent product designers, a single successful design can spawn dozens of counterfeits within days of listing, often sold at a fraction of the original price.
The OECD's 2025 "Mapping Global Trade in Fakes" report found that global trade in counterfeit goods reached USD $467 billion in 2021, representing 2.3% of total global imports. China accounted for 45% of all reported seizures. Clothing, footwear, and leather goods represented 62% of seized items, but product design categories including electronics, toys, and consumer goods are heavily affected. Around 65% of seizures now involve small parcels and mail shipments, reflecting how e-commerce has democratized counterfeiting—allowing anyone to sell knockoff products directly to consumers worldwide.
Scientific Instrument & Hardware Makers
2 evidence items
Open science hardware projects face a sustainability crisis mirroring the broader open-source funding gap: 60% of open-source maintainers remain unpaid for their work, according to the 2024 Tidelift State of the Open Source Maintainer Report. Many open science hardware projects emerge from academic labs or community initiatives but lack support to transition to self-sustaining operations. The Open Science Hardware Foundation was established to provide organisational support, fiscal sponsorship, and capacity building, but the fundamental tension persists: corporations and well-funded research institutions build on freely shared instrument designs while the original creators -- often early-career researchers or makers in the Global South -- capture no economic value. Open science hardware is generally perceived as lower quality than proprietary alternatives, creating a double bind where designers give away their work for free yet receive neither financial compensation nor professional recognition.
The 2025 tariff regime is reshaping the electronics supply chain in ways that disproportionately harm small and independent hardware makers. Russia, a key supplier of metals and minerals used in semiconductors, remains heavily sanctioned, and Ukraine's two largest semiconductor-grade neon producers -- responsible for 90% of U.S. neon supply -- shut down following the 2022 invasion, straining critical chip manufacturing inputs. Ongoing U.S.-China trade tensions have increased tariffs on semiconductor-related imports, reducing sourcing confidence and pipeline predictability. Small hardware engineers and scientific instrument builders lack the purchasing power to stockpile components or diversify suppliers across geographies. Unlike large manufacturers who can absorb tariff-driven cost increases, independent makers face existential risk: a single component becoming unavailable or doubling in price can render a custom instrument design financially unviable.
Urban Planning & Community Design
1 evidence item
NCRC's "Displaced by Design" report documents that 523 majority-Black neighborhoods experienced gentrification between 1980 and 2020, with 261,000 fewer Black residents in those areas and 155 neighborhoods undergoing full racial turnover from majority-Black to majority-white. Cities like Washington, D.C. saw 20,000 Black residents displaced. Over 60% of transportation and planning practitioners surveyed acknowledged that their projects were associated with gentrification and displacement, yet more than 60% said their agencies never allocated funding for displacement prevention—placing planners and community designers in an ethically untenable position where their professional work directly contributes to the harm of vulnerable communities.
Medical Illustrators & Healthcare Visual Creators
2 evidence items
A peer-reviewed study in Anatomical Sciences Education evaluated AI image generators (Midjourney, DALL-E, Stable Diffusion) for anatomical illustration and found significant clinical inaccuracies: foramina were frequently omitted, suture lines were inaccurately represented, heart illustrations failed to indicate proper coronary artery origins, branching of the aorta and pulmonary trunk was often incorrect, and brain illustrations lacked accurate gyri and sulci depiction. Despite these dangerous flaws, AI generators produce images in seconds at near-zero cost, creating market pressure to replace trained medical illustrators whose work undergoes rigorous anatomical verification — raising the specter of clinically inaccurate visuals entering medical education and patient communications.
Source: Evaluating AI-powered text-to-image generators for anatomical illustration: A comparative study - Noel et al., 2024 - Anatomical Sciences EducationA 2025 peer-reviewed study in Anatomical Sciences Education documented growing concerns around using existing anatomical illustrations — including AI-generated derivatives — to produce new illustrations for academic publishing, raising issues of copyright infringement and plagiarism. The study noted that this problem has become more prevalent with the proliferation of publishing platforms and the increased adoption of generative AI in academia. For medical illustrators, this represents a double threat: their original works are scraped to train AI models, and the resulting AI outputs are then published as "new" illustrations that compete with — and potentially replace — the originals, all without attribution, consent, or compensation to the original creator.
Source: Legal and ethical considerations around the use of existing illustrations to generate new illustrations in the anatomical sciences - Cornwall et al., 2025 - Anatomical Sciences EducationTherapeutic Arts Practitioners
2 evidence items
Art therapists are licensed in only 13 U.S. jurisdictions (Connecticut, Delaware, DC, Kentucky, Maryland, Mississippi, Nebraska, New Jersey, New Mexico, Ohio, Oregon, Tennessee, and Virginia). In the remaining 37+ states, anyone can call themselves an "art therapist" without the necessary master's-level training, clinical hours, or board certification. As the AATA states: "Without unique art therapy licensure, both art therapists and the public remain helpless to prevent unqualified individuals from practicing as so-called art therapists without the necessary training or credentials."
The proliferation of AI therapy chatbots — with apps like Wysa, Woebot, and ChatGPT-based tools increasingly marketed for mental health support — poses a disproportionate threat to creative arts therapists. While the therapeutic relationship and embodied creative process are central to art, music, dance, and drama therapy, few AI mental health apps have undergone rigorous clinical testing, and unlike human therapists, AI models are not held to strict medical standards. Creative arts therapists, who already face challenges proving their evidence base to insurers and policymakers, now confront a competitor that can undercut their fees to near-zero while operating entirely outside professional regulation.
Source: NPR - With Therapy Hard to Get, People Lean on AI for Mental HealthHealth Educators & Medical Content Creators
2 evidence items
The pharmaceutical industry funded approximately half of all U.S. continuing medical education costs, with industry support growing from $301 million to $1.2 billion between 1998 and 2007. The industry expects a return of $3.56 in increased sales for every dollar invested in CME, and 88% of clinicians surveyed acknowledged that commercial support introduces a greater risk of bias. Independent CME developers who refuse pharmaceutical sponsorship face a structural funding disadvantage, unable to compete with industry-backed programs that can offer lavish venues, free attendance, and extensive marketing. This creates a system where health educators must either compromise their independence or accept dramatically lower reach and compensation.
Unlicensed health influencers with millions of followers face lawsuits for deceptive marketing — Texas sued influencer Brittany Dawn Davis (1.3 million TikTok followers) for scamming customers with nutrition plans costing $92 to $300 that never delivered promised personalized coaching. Meanwhile, the FTC updated its Endorsement Guidelines to hold all parties in marketing campaigns liable for breaches, including content creators. Legitimate health educators face a double bind: they must comply with professional licensure, evidence standards, and liability frameworks that unlicensed wellness influencers ignore, yet the influencers' unregulated content attracts far larger audiences. Credentialed health educators who follow ethical guidelines are systematically outcompeted by those who don't.
Legal Content Creators & Policy Researchers
1 evidence item
NBC News reported that a growing number of people are using ChatGPT as a substitute for lawyers in court proceedings -- and some are starting to win. This trend emerges directly from the access-to-justice gap: with 92% of low-income civil legal problems going unaddressed and legal aid funding under threat, people increasingly turn to AI rather than human legal professionals. While this democratizes basic legal information, it creates systemic risks: AI-generated legal arguments may contain hallucinated citations, pro se litigants lack the judgment to evaluate AI output, and the trend further depresses demand for legal aid writers and public interest content creators whose work was designed to bridge exactly this gap.
Hardware Makers & Electronics Creators
2 evidence items
More than 52% of companies targeted in patent lawsuits by non-practicing entities (NPEs) between 2017 and 2022 had annual revenues under $25 million, according to a study by HighTech-Solutions. The average cost to defend an NPE lawsuit hovers around $4 million, with patent trolls deliberately timing suits to coincide with funding rounds or acquisition events to maximize pressure for settlement. Small hardware firms shoulder a disproportionate burden, with patent abuse consuming approximately a quarter of their R&D spending. The number of small firms sued by patent trolls grew from 800 in 2005 to nearly 2,900 in 2011, with the median defendant's annual revenue just $10.3 million -- a scale typical of independent hardware makers.
Amazon removed over seven million fake goods from its platform in 2023, with estimates suggesting 10-60% of products in some categories may be counterfeit. For hardware makers, counterfeits create a dual threat: fake electronics contribute to over 70 deaths and 350,000 serious injuries annually in the United States, and when counterfeit versions of a creator's product cause harm, the original maker's reputation suffers. CBS News reported that $2 trillion in counterfeit products are sold globally each year. Independent hardware creators lack the legal resources to police counterfeits across global marketplaces, and Amazon's commingled inventory system means even buyers purchasing from legitimate sellers may receive counterfeit goods, eroding trust in the entire independent hardware ecosystem.
3D Printing & Digital Fabrication
3 evidence items
The European Parliament adopted a resolution on 3 July 2018 --- with 631 votes in favour, 27 against, and 19 abstentions --- acknowledging that 3D printing poses fundamental challenges to intellectual property rights and civil liability that existing laws cannot address. The resolution called on the European Commission to consider new legislation, a specific liability regime, and greater public awareness of IP protections for 3D-printed works. Eight years later, the EU adopted the revised Design Regulation (2024/2822) and new Design Directive (2024/2823) strengthening protections for designs reproducible via 3D printing --- but enforcement remains largely theoretical, and individual creators still lack practical mechanisms to defend their work across borders.
The FDA's Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research has not published specific guidance on bioprinting --- the layer-by-layer positioning of biological materials --- nor approved any 3D-printed biological products. Traditional regulatory frameworks designed for mass-manufactured therapies cannot accommodate bespoke, patient-specific bioprinted constructs, and there is fundamental uncertainty over whether bioprinted products should be classified as drugs, medical devices, biologics, or combination products. Bioprinting researchers face a career paradox: the field requires years of specialized training in both biology and digital fabrication, yet the absence of clear regulatory pathways means commercial applications remain perpetually "five years away," trapping researchers in academic positions without viable industry career paths.
Source: The Pew Charitable Trusts - FDA's Regulatory Framework for 3D Printing of Medical Devices at the Point of Care Needs More ClarityA peer-reviewed study in Regenerative Medicine found that the lack of coherent national and international regulatory pathways represents a major barrier to the clinical translation and commercialization of bioprinted products. Bioprinting falls outside the scope of the FDA's "leapfrog guidance" for 3D printed medical devices, effectively leaving the field in regulatory limbo. The inclusion of living cells in the fabrication process adds a dimension of complexity that no existing regulatory framework was designed to address. For bioprinting researchers and digital fabrication specialists who have invested years of training in this convergent discipline, regulatory fragmentation between the US, EU, and Asia means that products approved in one jurisdiction may face entirely different classification requirements in another --- creating an unpredictable landscape that deters both investment and career commitment.
Source: Tandfonline - The Regulatory Challenge of 3D BioprintingRepair, Restoration & Conservation
2 evidence items
iFixit retroactively dropped the iPhone 14's repairability score after revealing that nearly half of iPhone parts are now "paired," meaning replacement parts require manufacturer-only proprietary software to function without triggering error messages or degraded performance. Even when a repairer installs a perfect, genuine OEM replacement part, the device will not work correctly without access to Apple's calibration or pairing software. iFixit applies a severe global scorecard penalty for parts pairing, noting that any repairability points gained through better physical design are negated if routine repairs cannot actually be completed outside of the manufacturer's authorized repair network. Oregon became the first US state to ban parts pairing in 2024, with its law taking effect January 1, 2025.
Source: iFixit - We Are Retroactively Dropping the iPhone's Repairability ScoreArt restorers and conservators face unique professional liability exposure: a single mistake on a valuable artwork can result in claims worth millions, as damaged pieces may suffer permanent diminution in value even after repair. Professional liability (Errors & Omissions) insurance is essential, covering situations where a client claims restoration damaged the original piece or lowered its value, with premiums reflecting the catastrophic financial risk. General liability, inland marine (covering objects in transit and in care), and professional liability policies must be layered to provide adequate coverage. For independent conservators and small restoration shops, these insurance costs represent a significant overhead burden that larger institutional conservation departments can absorb but solo practitioners struggle to afford, creating a barrier to independent practice.
Source: Business Insurance USA - Art Restorer Liability & Property InsuranceCommunity Organizers & Cultural Programmers
2 evidence items
Unpaid labour is endemic to cultural and creative work, with cultural events systematically dependent on volunteer exploitation. Edinburgh's Hogmanay celebrations advertised for 300 unpaid positions to run events for paying audiences. Among 224 arts freelancers surveyed, the average annual income was just £16,000. Unpaid internships and volunteer positions exclude those unable to work for free, effectively discriminating against all but the affluent and reinforcing class barriers in cultural programming. Volunteer Scotland estimated the value of unpaid volunteer work at £2.26 billion to the Scottish economy — labor that would otherwise need to be compensated.
Community event producers face escalating regulatory requirements that function as barriers to entry. Liability insurance minimums of $1-2 million are standard across US municipalities, with Chicago, Philadelphia, and Los Angeles County all requiring seven-figure general liability coverage naming the city as additional insured. Permit processes require coordination across multiple agencies — safety, health, noise, traffic, and community impact — with fee structures designed to recover administrative costs from organizers who are often volunteers directing any profits back to the community. These cumulative regulatory and financial burdens disproportionately exclude grassroots cultural organizers who lack institutional infrastructure.
Religious & Spiritual Content Creators
1 evidence item
The Gospel Coalition documents how sermon plagiarism has become widespread in evangelical churches, enabled by the internet's vast library of freely accessible sermon content. In a notable case, SBC president Ed Litton was found to have plagiarized sermons "nearly word for word" from another pastor for years, leading to the removal of over 140 sermons from his church's website. Commercial services now package and sell complete sermon content to pastors. The internet has acted as "kerosene on the fire" of pulpit plagiarism, creating an environment where original sermon writers see their creative intellectual work freely taken without attribution, while the theological and pastoral labor of crafting authentic sermons is systematically devalued.
Source: Pastor, Plagiarism Is More Than TheftOral Historians, Archivists & Cultural Memory Keepers
3 evidence items
AI bots designed to scrape training data for large language models are hammering the servers of libraries, archives, museums, and galleries, in some cases knocking their collections offline entirely. A GLAM-E Lab report (a joint initiative of the University of Exeter and NYU Law) surveyed 43 institutions with open online collections across Europe, North America, and Oceania: 39 of 43 reported a recent traffic increase, with 27 attributing it directly to AI training data bots. The bots do not respect licensing—both openly licensed and copyright-restricted collections are scraped, and licensing signals are neither read nor respected. Cultural heritage institutions are deploying home-grown and third-party firewall solutions, though few are confident these defenses will be sustainable long-term. The robots.txt protocol has proven ineffective at controlling bot swarms.
Indigenous data sovereignty—the right of Indigenous Peoples to own data about them, their communities, and their protocols, and control how it is accessed, used, and shared—remains systematically violated by museums, archives, and government entities holding Indigenous cultural materials without community consent. Digital repatriation involves returning data and digital surrogates from colonial institutions, but progress is slow. The CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance (Collective Benefit, Authority to Control, Responsibility, and Ethics) and Canada's OCAP principles (Ownership, Control, Access, Possession) provide frameworks, yet many institutions continue to treat Indigenous knowledge as open data. The Mukurtu content management system has empowered communities to build their own digital collections, but the fundamental power asymmetry persists: institutions hold the materials while communities must petition for access to their own heritage.
Source: PoLAR: Political and Legal Anthropology Review - Supporting Cultural Rights and Indigenous Sovereignty through Archival RepatriationThe Federal Trade Commission identified critical privacy risks in direct-to-consumer genetic testing and genealogical databases. Key concerns include perpetual, royalty-free, worldwide licenses to use customers' DNA data; warnings that DNA information may be used against "you or a genetic relative"; and waivers of legal rights buried in user agreements. A three-year collaboration between Ancestry and Calico (a Google spinoff) granted Calico access to Ancestry's databases, tools, and algorithms to analyze family longevity—raising alarm about the commercialization of genealogical research. Few restrictions exist on law enforcement's ability to access consumer genealogical databases, with only Maryland and Montana limiting forensic genealogy use. Since its 2023 Biometric Policy Statement, the FTC has settled actions against two DNA testing companies, and in June 2024, Canadian and UK regulators launched a joint investigation into 23andMe over breach safeguards.
Translators & Localization Specialists
1 evidence item
Research examining translators in the platform economy found that work is predominantly outsourced by businesses in the Global North to workers in the Global South to reduce costs. In Turkey, where translators face record inflation, currency depreciation, and high unemployment, platform work has become one of few options to earn in foreign currency. Hungarian agencies pay translators approximately 50% less than their UK or Ireland counterparts, while Indian translators average just $0.04 per source word -- with minimums as low as $0.01 per word. The study documented substantial disparities in meeting fundamental conditions of decent work, including insufficient earnings, excessive working hours, difficulties achieving work-life balance, and limited social security access.
Sports Coaches, Trainers & Movement Creators
2 evidence items
Approximately 65% of personal trainers in the UK fitness industry are self-employed, earning an average base salary of just £30,879 (approximately $39,000 USD). Self-employed trainers must absorb certification costs, liability insurance, CIMSPA professional membership, ongoing CPD training, and travel expenses — all without employer contributions to pensions, sick pay, or holiday pay. Cost-of-living pressures are further squeezing demand, as consumers increasingly view personal training as a "discretionary extra" — making trainer income inherently unstable and leaving the majority of the workforce without any employment protections or safety net.
The world's first global thematic report on sport trafficking, published by Loughborough University and Mission 89, reveals that an estimated 15,000 young players are trafficked yearly from West Africa alone with promises of becoming professional footballers. The global sports industry, valued at $471 billion to $1.4 trillion annually, has become a magnet for traffickers exploiting vulnerable athletes from the Global South through deceptive recruitment. In 2023, 47 young players -- including 36 minors from Africa, Asia, and South America -- were rescued by Portuguese authorities from a single football academy believed to be trafficking victims. The report defines sport trafficking as a systematic process of recruiting and exploiting individuals within the sporting domain through coercive mechanisms, extending to labor and sexual exploitation during mega sporting events.
Cartographers & Geospatial Creators
1 evidence item
Academic research on crowdsourced mapping ethics found that "all is not well in the world of crowdsourcing at the moment, especially concerning fairness, respect and economical sustainability for the contributors." The study documents how crowdsourced mapping "might be losing its synonymity with communities of voluntary, often leisure-time mappers and the digital commons, becoming instead a new form of exploited labor," with individual mappers "reduced to a clickworker." Contributors often do not fully understand how their data will be used beyond the immediate mapping project, and their mapping data becomes permanently accessible to third parties. This dynamic depresses market rates for all cartographic work by creating a parallel supply of free, commercially exploitable map data.
Source: Evaluating Current Ethical Values of OpenStreetMap Using Value Sensitive Design - Taylor & Francis / GeoInformaticaPerfumers & Sensory Experience Designers
2 evidence items
EU Commission Regulation 2023/1545 expanded the list of fragrance allergens requiring individual labeling from 26 to 80 substances when present above 0.001% in leave-on products. The IFRA 51st Amendment (2024) further restricted 48 new ingredients and revised limits on 11 existing ones. Compliance requires perfumers to reformulate existing compositions, retest stability, and source compliant substitutes -- adding 4-8 weeks of delay per formula. Products must comply by 31 July 2026. For small-scale and independent perfumers, these cascading regulatory requirements impose disproportionate compliance costs that large corporate houses absorb far more easily.
There is no national licensing requirement for aromatherapists in the United States, and neither aromatherapy nor essential oils are regulated by any governmental body. There is no official form of aromatherapy accreditation among professionals in the trade. The Aromatherapy Registration Council (ARC) offers voluntary registration via national examination, but this carries no legal standing. Certified aromatherapist salaries average $45,651/year, with most practitioners working part-time or independently and responsible for their own benefits. The absence of regulatory recognition leaves aromatherapists vulnerable to market saturation by untrained practitioners and unable to seek insurance reimbursement for clinical services.
Toy & Game Designers
2 evidence items
Counterfeit board games have reached crisis levels, with 55.18% of consumers surveyed having unintentionally purchased counterfeit toys and board games online. Counterfeiters in China scan artwork, create component molds, and mass-produce copies using cheaper, untested materials. Some counterfeits originate from "third shift work" where factory workers produce bootleg copies at night using stolen materials. Small indie publishers with minimal components like Oink Games are prime targets because their games are easy to replicate at high margins. Counterfeit games sold through Amazon and other marketplaces directly cannibalise legitimate sales while the original designers receive nothing. Publishers must spend their own limited resources policing counterfeits rather than designing new games.
Children's toys rank among the top 10 most counterfeited product categories worldwide. Spin Master Corp. fought cases against Chinese companies engaged in "malicious infringement" of PAW Patrol and Bakugan IP rights, involving mass production of counterfeit and knockoff toys. Counterfeit toys bypass strict safety standards and regulations, posing direct risks to children. For independent toy inventors and puzzle creators, enforcing IP rights across international jurisdictions requires legal resources that dwarf their revenue. The combination of easy digital replication of designs, low-cost overseas manufacturing, and marketplace platforms that struggle to police listings creates a system where original creators bear all the risk of innovation while counterfeiters capture the profits.
Source: KURZ SCRIBOS - The Problem of Counterfeiting in the Toy IndustryFlorists, Landscape & Garden Designers
1 evidence item
AI-generated floral arrangement images are flooding Pinterest and social media, creating a significant disconnect from reality. Wedding clients arrive with AI-generated "inspiration" images featuring shapes, sizes, and color combinations that don't exist in nature. If too many companies use fake images, customers may stop trusting the entire floral industry. Florists report that AI-generated images are "a bit ridiculous with shapes and sizes that aren't even close to real," yet they must spend unpaid consultation time explaining what is physically possible -- or risk client dissatisfaction and negative reviews when real arrangements cannot match algorithmically perfected fantasies.
Source: Archer & Bliss Floral - AI Images & Artificial Flowers: How to Identify What is RealTaxidermists, Preparators & Natural History Creators
1 evidence item
CITES affords varying degrees of protection to over 35,000 species of animals and plants, and its regulations apply to any "readily recognizable part or derivative thereof," including taxidermy mounts. Taxidermists working with legally sourced specimens must navigate a labyrinth of permits for import, export, and interstate transport, with violations carrying severe criminal penalties. Moving any listed species across international borders requires CITES documentation even for personal or museum use. For taxidermists specializing in exotic or antique mounts, the compliance burden is substantial: pre-Convention specimen exemptions require provenance documentation that may be decades old, and regulatory uncertainty deters collectors from commissioning new work. This framework, while essential for conservation, creates significant legal exposure for legitimate practitioners.
Calligraphers, Lettering Artists & Type Designers
3 evidence items
Type designers face critical unresolved questions about how foundries and designers can protect their fonts from being used to train generative AI models, whether their clients or distributors are allowed to use their fonts for AI training, and what legal recourse designers have when their work is scraped. AI font generation tools now promise to create custom typefaces in seconds rather than the months or years of skilled labour traditionally required. The Font Business Conference 2025 identified font protection and rights under law as "crucial to the health and wellbeing of the industry," as the AI-powered design tools market surges from $5.54 billion in 2024 toward a projected $40.15 billion by 2034.
Under U.S. case law and Copyright Office regulation, typeface designs are not eligible for copyright protection — only the underlying font software code may be protected. This creates a fundamental legal paradox where the visual work a type designer spends months or years crafting has no direct copyright shield. The "software" route is becoming less straightforward as modern tools like Glyphs automate much of what was manual code generation, and the Copyright Office is increasingly refusing registration where a human did not create the specific code claimed. Some foundries report receiving as much revenue from enforcement ("retroactive license sales") as from normal licensing, revealing how broken the compensation model has become.
Source: Communication Arts - Fonts and the LawCalligraphy itself is not protected by copyright law because fonts, typefaces, lettering, and calligraphy are considered variations of the alphabet — a "building block of expression." This leaves calligraphers and hand lettering artists with minimal legal recourse when their work is stolen and reproduced on print-on-demand products, copied by social media accounts, or used without attribution. Thieves routinely resell stolen artwork files to manufacturers and print-on-demand sellers. Even when artists pursue legal action, if they have not registered their work with the copyright office before the theft occurs, they can only collect the offender's profit — often negligible — rather than the potentially significant statutory damages available for pre-registered work.
Source: Crooked Calligraphy - Calligraphy and Copyright Laws (Explained by a Lawyer)Pyrotechnicians & Special Effects Creators
5 evidence items
A representative of The Union of British Columbia Performers, which represents 560 stunt performers, confirms a 100% injury rate among its members — catastrophic accidents, head injuries, substance abuse, anxiety, depression, and suicide have impacted every stunt performer in the community. Despite this, injuries routinely go unreported: performers fear being blacklisted, losing future work, or being perceived as unreliable. As one veteran performer put it, "A lot of injuries get covered up, quite frankly." The profession has no equivalent to the concussion protocols that protect athletes in professional sports.
Between 2002 and 2024, 152 catastrophic incidents — defined as fatalities or serious injuries — were reported on film and television sets, resulting in 32 deaths. The leading causes were falls (from ladders, catwalks, and rigging), followed by motor vehicle crashes during filming and stunt-related accidents. The deadliest year was 2011, with 5 deaths — 4 from falls. Workers categorized as "Laborers, except construction" were the most likely to be killed or injured, followed by "actors and directors." OSHA has documented over 40 stunt-related deaths in the U.S. film industry since 1980.
As Hollywood's content boom strains the ranks of seasoned stunt professionals, productions are hiring haphazardly and cutting safety corners. There are no SAG-AFTRA requirements stipulating qualifications for becoming a stunt coordinator — "If you have a SAG card, you can work as an actor, a stuntperson or a stunt coordinator." An official from SAG-AFTRA acknowledged that the jump in productions and their geographic dispersion creates "an increased risk of unqualified stunt coordinators" putting lives at risk. In one documented case, producers failed to place safety pads under sand where a performer crash-landed a Jet Ski at 28 mph, resulting in traumatic brain injury. Stunt performers report that SAG-AFTRA safety regulations have "no teeth."
Source: The Hollywood Reporter - Stunted: How Hollywood's Content Boom Is Leading to More Stuntperson Injuries and DeathsOn July 1, 2025, a pyrotechnics warehouse explosion in Esparto, California killed 7 workers and injured 2 others. Cal/OSHA issued 15 citations totaling $221,000 to Devastating Pyrotechnics, including failures to establish an Injury and Illness Prevention Program, train employees on emergency evacuation procedures, and train workers on fire hazards associated with explosive materials. The company also failed to immediately notify Cal/OSHA of the deaths. A subsequent State Fire Marshal investigation revealed "evidence of illegal activities," and the company's owner had previously been denied an ATF license following a criminal conviction — meaning he was legally ineligible to possess explosive materials.
WorkSafe Queensland issued a safety warning following the death of a stunt actor on an Australian film production, highlighting the lethal consequences of inadequate firearms and pyrotechnics safety protocols on set. In Australia, only accredited stunt performers graded by MEAA's National Stunt Committee across 6 skill categories (Body Control, Heights, Vehicles, Animals, Water, and Fire) may perform stunt actions — yet enforcement varies by state and territory. Research into Australian stunt performers revealed themes of "injury reporting stigma" and a "prevailing cowboy culture," with the Australian Stunts Organisation calling for specialized healthcare facilities and mental health support as performers struggle financially to maintain fitness and recover from injuries.
Where the pattern shows up most clearly
These discipline pages currently carry the strongest concentration of evidence for this issue.
Music
1 linked evidence items connect this concern to musicians creators.
Open discipline pageAudio & Podcasting
1 linked evidence items connect this concern to audio creators.
Open discipline pageArchitecture & Design
1 linked evidence items connect this concern to architecture creators.
Open discipline pageVisual Arts
2 linked evidence items connect this concern to visual arts creators.
Open discipline pageFilm & Video
1 linked evidence items connect this concern to film video creators.
Open discipline pageWriting & Publishing
1 linked evidence items connect this concern to writing publishing creators.
Open discipline pageRecurring problem categories inside this issue
These labels are counted directly from the current evidence items for this concern.
Sexual harassment and gender-based discrimination
1 evidence item
Online Harassment & Gendered Abuse
1 evidence item
Workplace Discrimination and Sexual Misconduct
1 evidence item
Unauthorized AI scraping of artwork
1 evidence item
Creator roles already named in this issue set
The issue is not abstract. These are some of the creator roles explicitly referenced in the evidence.
Women and gender minorities in music
Podcasters / Audio Journalists
Architects / All Designers
Visual Artist / Illustrator
Visual Artist
Cinematographers / Below-the-Line Crew
Continue through the evidence network
See this issue through the music evidence set.
Audio & PodcastingSee this issue through the audio & podcasting evidence set.
Architecture & DesignSee this issue through the architecture & design evidence set.
Issues indexBrowse every issue page currently available.
The HubReturn to the main evidence library.
Help fix this
70 evidence items document how safety & harassment affects creators across 43 disciplines. Sign the declaration to demand systemic change.